The power of a story to be conveyed in a film is not determined only by its shots beauty. The director’s skill to narrate a story effectively is equally important how effectively the director manages to narrate a story or a series of events by means of visuals. While rejecting dialogue, this task becomes even more complicated, as characters' actions, expressions, and the relationships between them if it establishes not only a mood but also helps the audience understand the unfolding events. In this regard, Tinatin Emiridze’s short narrative film “Black Sea” (2021) is interesting; it deals with a family tragedy and the attempt to resist a loss.
The loss of a loved one alters a family’s daily life. Sometimes, grief becomes so prolonged that individuals struggle to get along with one another. The pain of the past intrudes into the present, disrupting the familiar rhythm of life. The characters in “Black Sea” are in such a state; their existence seems to have come to a standstill, and the relationships among family members are shrouded in sorrow. While the director attempts to show this situation, the audience is given little insight into the events that led them to this point.
One of the film’s key symbols is the four plates placed on the dining table, even though only three family members are seated there. They look at the fourth, empty plate. This detail implies that the family has not forgotten the person they have lost; however, despite the emotional load of the scene, it is unclear what is hidden behind this symbol. The plate expresses well the pain caused by an absence, though it cannot explain its reason.
The essence of the plot becomes clear only after reading the synopsis: the family lost their son at sea. Knowing this provides specific meaning for the events seen on screen. The fourth plate represents the place of the deceased son, while the girl’s actions reflect a desire to free the family from their grief. However, a question is raised here: why does the viewer need a synopsis to understand what is happening in the film? The purpose of a synopsis is to provide a brief overview of a work, not to fill in gaps in the narrative. When viewers have to deduce key events on their own, the ambiguity makes the story difficult to perceive.
Throughout the fifteen-minute film, the characters’ state remains almost unchanged. Sadness, silence, and a heavy mood are constantly felt on screen, though these feelings lack development. The melancholic atmosphere established at the beginning gradually becomes monotonous, as the repetitive depiction of these emotions reveals almost nothing new about the characters. The family members remain in the same state, as a result, the film’s dramatic structure clearly falters.
There are only two significant changes in the film: the burning of the boat and the change in music. For the father, the boat is a way to maintain a connection to the past; its destruction represents an attempt to break that chain, allowing him to envision a life beyond the loss. On the other hand, replacing the sad music signifies the introduction of new energy into their daily lives. Both actions share a common goal: to liberate the family from the heavy state in which they found themselves following the tragedy. This, in essence, is the film’s central message: coming to terms with a loss does not mean forgetting the past, yet a tragedy should not define one’s entire life.
The girl is the most active figure in the film, yet her decisions are insufficient to drive the plot forward. In “Black Sea,” the actions remain mere isolated, symbolic episodes. Furthermore, the character’s inner state is barely explored. As a member of the same family, she also experiences the loss of her brother as a tragedy; however, the film focuses primarily on the parents' grief. The heaviest aspect of this drama is the parents' indifference. Trapped in the pain of the past and consumed by mourning their deceased child, the parents barely seem to notice the existence of their other child. To them, the girl’s inner world becomes insignificant, leaving her isolated within her own home. The parents spare all their energy to preserve something that no longer exists, effectively disregarding the present and future of their living child.
The confined space of the house further intensifies the characters' internal states. Daily life within four walls, points not only to the family’s isolation but also to the fact that this environment acts as a kind of trap for each of them. The home, a place that ought to be a sanctuary of safety and intimacy, has become a space in the film defined by silence and alienation, where every character is left completely alone with their own pain.
The internal conflict among family members could have been particularly interesting for the plot development. The parents are entirely left in the memory of their deceased child, seemingly failing to notice the daughter who still has her whole life ahead of her. This alienation creates a profound sense of injustice. The mourning of the past stands in opposition to a living person’s natural desire to move on with their life. It is precisely from this tension that the central dramatic conflict could have emerged; however, the film bypasses this opportunity.
Reading “Black Sea” script might prove more interesting than watching the film itself. The episodes presented on screen feel like fragments of a larger story whose connecting threads have been lost. It is interesting that a film which almost entirely neglects words, ultimately leaves one feeling the very need for them; there appears a desire that the story had also been presented in written form, so that the characters' inner motivations might become clearer.
Despite these flaws, the film’s visual aspect and the topic chosen by the director are noteworthy. An aesthetic vision is evident in certain shots, while a melancholic mood blends naturally with the family’s difficult situation. Ultimately, the viewer is more likely to remember specific visual elements – such as the four plates or the burnt boat rather than the story itself.
Tinatin Emiridze’s “Black Sea” is a film with an interesting idea that remains not fully realized. While the director succeeds in conveying the sorrow born of loss, a coherent narrative fails to emerge from beneath the film’s visual beauty and melancholic atmosphere. Silence, intended to be the film’s primary artistic device, proves insufficient to mask its dramaturgical weaknesses. The motivations behind the characters' actions remain unclear, and their relationships fail to develop in any meaningful way. Consequently, “Black Sea” remains little more than a collection of individual, striking shots.
Barbare Kalaijishvili






